Two of three locations go to “coming soon” criticalThe Location menu lists Atlanta, Conyers and Decatur, but Conyers and Decatur open “New Website Coming Soon” pages. The hero says “This site is for the ATLANTA – BRIARCLIFF RD ONLY.”
Your most famous store has no web presence criticalConyers has the 855 reviews and the Keith Lee award, and its Google profile’s “website” link points to the Toast ordering page instead of sharpirospizza.com.
The page title says the wrong cityThe homepage’s title tag and site name read “Sharpiros Pizzeria – Conyers” while the page is for Atlanta. Every inner page (Catering, Contact) repeats it. The homepage is also tagged as an “article”.
Images are template placeholdersMenu tiles, reviewer photos and icons use the theme’s placeholder.png and images hot-linked from the template vendor’s demo server (shthemes.net).
The three reviews are identical template text trust“John Morris”, “Kelly Minar” and “Maria May” all share the same paragraph and the same “5 star of 20 review” label, while you have 639 real five-star Google reviews.
The menu is a 2.3 MB PDFNo items or prices are on the page itself (only “Slices starting at $5.00”), so Google can’t index “jerk oxtail pizza Conyers” and phones have to download a tabloid PDF.
No hours anywhere on the websiteCustomers have to leave for Google or Toast to see whether you’re open.
Hours disagree across listingsGoogle shows Conyers closed on Mondays. The Toast banner and Apple Maps say Monday–Saturday 11–10, and Toast runs a $5 Monday MEGA slice.
Two different Conyers phone numbers(770) 679-5976 on Google and Apple, and (470) 276-6966 on directory sites. Mismatched NAP data hurts map rankings.
The name is split two ways“Sharpiros” on the site and menus, “Shapiro’s” in the logo file and in press (“Shapiro’s Pizzeria opening soon”). Customers search both, and only one is wired up.
Social icons don’t link anywhereFacebook, Twitter, YouTube and Instagram are labels only, while the printed menu says “Follow and tag us @sharpirospizza.”
“80 wing flavors” vs. 32 on the menuThe homepage advertises 80; the printed menu lists 32. Pick one number and own it.
The Keith Lee story is missingYour biggest proof point appears once, as “Keith Lee Approved” in small type on the PDF.
Toast uses AI/stock-looking wing photosThe wing, tender, mozzarella-stick and popper photos on Toast look generated or stock, even though you already posted a real wing photo that looks better.
Atlanta Toast is “not accepting online orders”As of Nov 18, 2026, the homepage’s Order Now button led to a Toast page that wasn’t taking orders, and the Atlanta Google profile has 2 reviews and no photos.
Decatur is hiring with nowhere to send peopleAn Indeed post for cooks and cashiers in Decatur (30032) is live, but the Decatur page says you can only order from Conyers.
Catering is a flyer with no formThe Catering page shows the flyer image and “Coming Soon”. There’s no way to send an inquiry, and the footer still reads © 2025.